Menu

To order pie, please call or email us.
Current Seasonal Menu (4/29-5/2)
These pies are almost always available in our store and are available for pre-order. Pies by the slice are subject to availability. (Preorders due by 12pm previous day)

To order, call or email info@ilovepiebakeshop.com. (Include date, time of pick up and phone number with your order.)

Pies 8 inch – $22
Cheesecakes 6 inch and 8 inch – $15/28 (Preorder 48 hrs)
Quiche 9 inch – $26
Salted Caramel Dutch Apple Pie
Strawberry Crumb Pie
Strawberry Rhubarb (double crust)
Banana Cream Pie
Chocolate Cream Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Honey Walnut Pie
Key Lime Pie
Crème Brûlée Pie (Whole only)
Ham, Cheddar, Potato Quiche (preorder Weekend)

International Harry Potter Day! Butterbeer Pie! MAY 1 & 2
Butterscotch pastry cream, topped with meringue and a praline sauce. (No nuts)

WE SELL WHOLE PIES & PIE BY THE SLICE IN OUR STORE. THE PIE FLAVORS LISTED ON THIS MENU ARE AVAILABLE FOR PRE-ORDER. PLEASE CALL US DURING BUSINESS HOURS TO PLACE AN ORDER IN ADVANCE. WE ALWAYS HAVE A SELECTION OF FRESH WHOLE PIES IN-STORE AVAILABLE FOR PURCHASE FIRST COME, FIRST SERVED. PRE-ORDERS MUST BE PLACED NO LATER THAN NOON THE DAY BEFORE PICK-UP *SUBJECT TO AVAILABILITY

CURBSIDE PICK UP AVAILABLE!

Covid-19 Precautions in place. Please call our shop with questions or concerns.

1.  Pick up. We are still open for normal to-go orders in the shop. Please consider the 6 feet social distancing recommendations for safety. Masks are currently required for entry.

2. Curbside pickup. Call before you arrive or after you arrive to place an order and we will bring it out to your car.