Online Ordering

Order here to pick up in-store! For Delivery Options, CLICK HERE!
October Menu! (10/1/24 – 10/31/2024)
FOR THANKSGIVING ORDERS, PLEASE VISIT OUR HOLIDAY ORDERING PAGE .
SOME ITEMS ON OUR OCTOBER & NOVEMBER REGULAR MENU MAY NOT BE AVAILABLE. <3
For catering or bulk orders, please reach out to us at info@ilovepiebakeshop.com

Banana Cream Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Bourbon Pecan Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Chocolate Cream Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Chocolate Graveyard Pie

$32.00

Select options
Classic Apple Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Classic Cheesecake

$24.00 – $42.00

Select options
Classic Chicken Pot Pie (Take & Bake)

$15.00 – $39.00

Select options
Coconut Cream Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Fall Gift Box (Petite 3″ pies)

$33.00 – $66.00

Select options
Fluted Pie Shell

$6.00 – $10.00

Select options
Ham Potato Cheddar Quiche

$15.00 – $32.00

Select options
Lemon Meringue Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Pie Pops

$3.00

Select options
Pumpkin Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options
Salted Caramel Dutch Apple Pie

$15.00 – $28.00

Select options

Special Order Pies (off-menu)
Are you in search of a pie that is not on our current menu, then give us a call! We will try to accommodate your special request.